A photo posted by Yancy Hughes Dominick (@yancy9) on
Surprising amount of fun representing the Philosophy Department at a recent open house for accepted students who are considering attending Seattle U. Fun mostly because of the super helpful and enthusiastic philosophy majors who helped out:
Lots to say, but first how about a quiet moment of anticipation with Franklin and Beckham:
Watching West Seattle High School baseball practice. (Thanks to B's mom for the great photo!)
Meanwhile, just a little recap. Franklin likes my Plato mug (best gift from a student ever!), and the other day asked about Plato's books.
I started reading the beginning of the Republic. He was surprisingly patient (and kept asking for more), and asked some great questions, like what is wealth, and eventually "what does justice mean"?
Maybe my favorite though was when he didn't understand what Socrates meant when he said he had an appetite for conversation. I tried explaining that it meant something like being hungry for conversation, which Franklin found hilarious—kept repeating the phrase and giggling all morning :)
And as for hungry, how about these nascent chopsticks skills!
Oh but speaking of Plato, less giggly scene at the International Plato Society meeting in Atlanta. Great experience though.
I have been working on book 10 of Plato's Laws lately, and gave a paper about that. I won't go into the details now (but maybe I'll post the handout at some point...), but I do want to share one of my favorite quotes, which mostly made it into my paper.
Laws 10 is all about what to do with troublesome atheists, deists, and folks who believe gods can be bribed or bought off. Anyway, there's a great bit in response to the idea that gods don't care about us:
ὧν ἓν καὶ τὸ σόν, ὦ σχέτλιε, μόριον εἰς τὸ πᾶν συντείνει βλέπον ἀεί, καίπερ πάνσμικρον ὄν, σὲ δὲ λέληθεν περὶ τοῦτο αὐτὸ ὡς γένεσις ἕνεκα ἐκείνου γίγνεται πᾶσα, ὅπως ᾖ τῷ τοῦ παντὸς βίῳ ὑπάρχουσα εὐδαίμων οὐσία, οὐχ ἕνεκα σοῦ γιγνομένη, σὺ δ’ ἕνεκα ἐκείνου
Translation: Now then, you stubborn fellow, one part of the universe is you—a mere speck that nevertheless constantly contributes to the good of the whole; but you have forgotten that nothing is created except to provide the entire universe with a happy life. You forget that creation is not for your benefit: you exist for the sake of the universe (903c)
Very charming, no? I can't help but also add this bit on the punishment that people like me would face if they ever moved to the city described in the Laws:
Consider first a complete atheist: he may have a naturally just character and be the sort of person who hates scoundrels, and because of his loathing of injustice is not tempted to commit it; he may flee the unjust and feel fondness for the just. Alternatively, besides believing that all things are ‘empty of’ gods, he may be a prey to an uncontrollable urge to experience pleasure and avoid pain, and he may have a retentive memory and be capable of shrewd insights. Both these people suffer from a common failing, atheism, but in terms of the harm they do to others the former is much less dangerous than the latter....
The dissembling atheist deserves to die for his sins not just once or twice but many times, whereas the other kind needs simply admonition combined with incarceration (908b-e)
I mean, um, that seems fair, right? ;)
What else? Had some fun with the end (alas) of basketball season:
Getting pretty good at the alma mater too:
Thanks for the photo, Wendy!
As of now the big question seems to be, will Franklin ever wear another shirt, and if so, when?
And thanks to Emily for getting me one to wear with him!
Okay, I can't resist one more Plato thing. Just saw this in the latest issue of Phronesis, a leading journal for Ancient Philosophy:
Check out note 14! Woo!
And if you want to read (or maybe re-read?) Dominick 2010, I've posted it online.
Other big news (bigger than a footnote? maybe...) is my new role as Associate Director (!) of the Seattle U Core Honors program, but maybe I'll wait and say more once I've actually started.
Now that awards season is in full swing, here'a quick word on some of our 2014 favorites.
I was thrilled to see that Gina Rodriguez won a Golden Globe for Jane the Virgin. Great show:
Having trouble finding good links, since in many cases the rave reviews—like the one in the New Yorker—came in articles about more than one show, which doesn't seem quite fair... But, well, I guess that's what the awards are making up for :)
And no harm in noting that the average from 21 "top critics" on Rotten Tomatoes is, yes, a not so shabby 100%.
In many ways it's quite different, but my other 2014 favorite is Mozart in the Jungle, which shares a kind of dreamy a-bit-more-than-realist tone.
Such a great show. We already watched the whole season (in barely a week), and I'm already looking forward to re-watching it, the sooner the better!
We recently read a pile of lists of the best albums of 2014, and picked up a few, allquitegood. Hands down, though, my favorite is the New Pornographers:
Haven't seen quite as many movies as we'd have liked, but recently saw a couple of solid entries.
A movie about a computer scientist and philosopher? Named after a section of a philosophy paper he wrote? Yes. Doesn't hurt that the cast is great and the story is incredible either.
Also fun at first was the cryptic crossword referenced in the movie (solve it in 12 minutes or less and come help the British crack the German enigma code!). Fun at first, until I realized that there was no way I was going to solve it any time soon...
Well, that's about all for now. Meanwhile the award for best Halloween costume of 2013 (yes, 2013) goes to... the bee! Franklin spotted it after his bath tonight and insisted on wearing it for a while:
Cheers, and congratulations to all the nominees!
Just in time for the most wonderful time, this year's school photos:
Warms my heart.
Speaking of which, it's also that time of year when I try to take stock of what we've been doing with our money and whether any of it's been well spent...
So, here's the latest breakdown:
More going toward those most in need and less toward music and whatnot. And yes, if you're tracking it from the last couple of years, that's partly on account of Peter Singer and his damned compelling reasoning. Not only that, but some friends hosted a book club meeting a couple months ago about his book The Life You Can Save, which really only made things clearer...
Anyway, I kind of struggle with what to say in this kind of blog post.
I mean, I want to make this somehow more than an annual ritual of congratulation and flagellation, but it's hard to get past those superficial moments. Yes, I am proud of the fact that we are giving away this much of our income. And yes, I am disappointed when I do the math and see that we spent more on vacations in 2014 than we did on helping others...
To put that another way, although I can pat myself on the back because we give to the King County United Way at the "Leadership" level, we're still not even close to giving 5% of our income.
Well, damn it. Here's a commitment to up our United Way and Oxfam giving in 2015. 5% or bust! Damn it!
Meanwhile, where are we spending money on ourselves? Let me count the ways ;)
How about: Had some fun watching KU come back and win against Florida last weekend:
(And how about that win at Georgetown yesterday?)
And a little holiday fun at the West Seattle Farmers Market:
Horse-drawn carriage? Mule-drawn carriage? Whatever—it was charming and they had jingling bells on...
Hope you're feeling that holiday spirit, reader! More soon!
Well it's official and before you know it we'll have a balcony with this view, overlooking the rest of the city from our new place in West Seattle:
I hope you'll come enjoy the view, reader!
Maybe warm up by the fire next winter?
Anyway, bottom line is that we'll be renting a unit here:
It's definitely going to be rough to have to leave Capitol Hill, but I do think the new neighborhood looks pretty good. And it's very encouraging to see that our new address is considered a "walker's paradise" on walkscore.com:
My commute doesn't look too bad:
And they don't even mention that there's also a water taxi to West Seattle!
All right, so, now to actually move... Got some boxes from the movers:
And at least one of us is eager to start packing:
But in some brilliantly inconvenient planning, I'm about to fly to California for this year's West Coast Plato Workshop. One last chance to rest and relax before the big move...
Okay, that title's a quote taken out of context (see below), and it's meant to be not truth but rather aspiration. This time of year our thoughts of course turn to questions about giving, and I thought I'd share an update since last year's post about our giving.
Thankfully, the Times did another story too, this time with lots of helpful links and even more Peter Singer references.
As you can see, our distribution is relatively unchanged from last year: a questionable commitment to the arts even though we know that helping people living in extreme poverty is the only morally justifiable choice. I guess we could pat ourselves on the back for giving almost 30% to Oxfam while the US average for overseas giving is just 6%, but I think our first step for 2014 should be telling Oxfam that we'll up our monthly gift.
Now you might wonder about the stuff further down the list: is the Nation Magazine a charity? Well, we subscribe but never read it, so I put in on there. On the other hand, we hardly ever use our YMCA memberships... if you put even half of the cost of that onto the chart, it would actually rank above the radio stations.
It would still, alas, not get us to the 5% mark...
The cool calculator the Times linked to agrees that we should be up closer to 5%. What's worse, we're actually down from last year. I'm ashamed to say that although a pay raise explains part of the decrease in the percentage we're giving away, we also let a couple of things slip and just forgot.
Emily and I are discussing sending a one-time end of the year gift—probably to, yes, Oxfam—to offset our mistake a little, but even if that happens we likely won't make 5%.
Where are you at on all of this, reader? What's a good distribution? What kind of percentage do you think makes sense?
Personally, my hope at this point is that writing about it now will make it a little harder to ignore in 2014. Tune in next year to see how it goes!
[Clunky transition alert!] Speaking of tuning, we've been enjoying some wonderful music during this season of giving.
First, take a listen to Franklin's rendition of Old McDonald:
And Sunday took us to St. Joseph Church for the Seattle U Festival of Christmas. Truly beautiful music. Glad we got to share it with Grandma Christine this year!
Also the source of the title of this post, which is a partial quote of a line from In the Bleak Midwinter, one of the songs we heard yesterday. Nothing like hearing it live, but if you want you can listen to another version On YouTube.
While we're here talking about atheists who love Christmas music, I have to tell you about this amazing story on NPR the other day. Actually, take a listen:
I can't remember the last time something made me smile this much.
In fact, I can't stop yet. Here's their version of Angels We Have Heard on High:
Man I love this time of year!
Okay fine, here are the pictures of Franklin. Helping to decorate the tree:
In Plato's Timaeus of course time is defined as "a moving image of eternity." A great line, and one we were reminded of recently: it's one of the quotes at the beginning of Tasha Tudor's A Time to Keep, a book that my Aunt Dorothy gave me when I was just about the age that Franklin is now, and a book that Grandma Christine found recently, which means now Franklin too can enjoy it.
Anyway, some days I really wish I had a little more time—even an extra hour—so I could do things like upload Thanksgiving photos.
And then sure enough Franklin sleeps in and what do I do but flip through a magazine and end up right back where I started...
So, okay, what were we talking about?
Had a great Thanksgiving. Thanks all!
Luckily we had a great helper in the kitchen:
Great company too of course:
And if you were wondering about the pie, it was awesome:
Afterwards we had a nice quiet weekend. Good chance for a stroll around the neighborhood:
Also a nice quiet time for Franklin's first haircut at a salon:
Pretty sweet setup at Kids Club. And a commemorative photo-card:
Long weekend also meant good chance to try on some clothes that we've been waiting to grow into:
Turns out Franklin really enjoys saying the phrase "baseball shirt":
Thanks again, Grandpa Ray & Grandma Rhonda!
But most exciting of all we had time to get our tree!
(From the awesome place across the street of course!)
Haven't quite finished decorating it, but Emily and Franklin got off to a strong start:
Hope you're keeping warm this December, reader!
Couple of guys in fleece hoodies, bravely facing the brightness of the coming holiday season:
Thanks to Pete for the photo!
Lot of cooking to be done this week. Franklin got in some good practice the other day:
Emily was out of town and it was way too cold to go out for a walk, so we made black beans together. He peeled the onion himself, helped me rinse the beans, and helped get everything into the pot.
He also really likes adding salt, but tends to get a little, well, excited...
But hey, they tasted great, so I'll take it!
And now we're on to Thursday's feast. First step: roasting some pumpkin for our pie:
Going to try the recipe on the Times' cool Thanksgiving page.
I may have said this before, but Melissa Clark is awesome.
You know what? See for yourself—here's the video:
Meanwhile Emily was working on the advanced preparations for one of the most important parts of the meal: spiced vermouth for the Holiday Manhattans!
All right, I should run. Little more work to get through before the rest of the cooking. Speaking of work, my Greek reading group met yesterday, and I discovered this wonderful line by Plato:
ἅπτει γάρ πώς μου τοῖς λόγοις τῆς ψυχῆς, ὦ Σώκρατες somehow you touch my soul with your words, Socrates
(Ion 535a)
I mean, that about sums it up!
So, back to the words... and I'll see you soon with more food.
Just a coincidence that Franklin spent an afternoon transfixed by the guitar two days before the Times ran a story on the benefits of music lessons?
Either way, sounds good to me!
He's also been busy cleaning up at daycare. Not always clear why you'd want, for example, to sweep up rain puddles in a sandbox, but there you go:
I love that his classmates paused to smile for Emily's camera while Franklin was just too busy to take a break.
Did pause the other day to look at some recent issues of the Journal of the History of Philosophy:
He insisted that I look at one while he flipped through another. Cute, yes, but also helpful: he pointed me to an article on Aristotle that I think will prove quite helpful in the classroom. Not bad!
Speaking of journal articles, you know how I was working on a paper on Plato's Symposium a few years ago, and then the Classical Quarterly said they'd publish it?
Well, I'm happy to say that now it's finally out! Woo! Feel free to take a look—I'd love to know what you think!
Oh, and as I mentioned on Facebook the other day, Franklin really loves apples. Ate all of this one:
I mean all—seeds, core... eventually Emily asked where the stem was and he smiled and spit it out.
And I mean, they are delicious, especially this time of year.
Okay, speaking of this time of year, I'm still finding great shots from our walk through the Arboretum last month:
Hope you enjoy it while it lasts!